|
|
|
Teaching
English - Teachers Talk Teaching
Doug Bruce
|
At the time of this interview Doug
was teaching at Clarence High School on Hobarts
Eastern Shore. When he was at school, the idea of being
a teacher never remotely entered his mind, but having
been inspired by some good English teachers as a senior
student, and developing his own love of literature, he
has made a career of sharing his appreciation with others.
One of Dougs particular interests is in exploring
different avenues for students to express and develop
ideas. In this interview, he talks about: encouraging
students interaction through cooperative learning:
teaching literature: and using technology to develop students
thinking and enhance the quality of their work. |
 |
|
Click
play to hear Doug's greeting.
|
Doug's
greeting requires the QuickTime Plug-in - click on
the icon right >>
to download it
|
 |
|
|
The
English program
Self-evaluation
and reflection
Classroom
organisation
- student
grouping and cooperative learning
I
have small old-fashioned desks with little grooves in them
where kids put their pencils and so forth, so I have them
set up in groups of six where they face each other. The
desks are set on a diagonal axis so that the students only
have to turn slightly and they can see the board and they
can see me. Basically the primary interaction is with one
another, but I can see every kid at least side on all the
time. I can kind of get a feel for whats happening
in their minds most of the time, I hope! I like to be able
to see whether theyre switched on to what theyre
doing or not, but basically the purpose of this style of
classroom arrangement is that theyre interacting with
one another. I want them to be sharing their ideas and to
easily be able to swap work across the table. More teachers
at this school are doing this. Most have arranged their
tables in groups so that kids can talk and share, which
is good. Im constantly moving kids around, mixing
and remixing groups so that they dont get over-comfortable
and kind of complacent just being able to give each other
pats on the back. They are working in different sorts of
groups in those situations so that they hear what somebody
else has to say. They learn to work with different people
and reshape some of their ideas and hear what other people
have to say. I constantly dip in to Barrie Bennetts
cooperative learning strategies. I dont use cooperative
learning strategies exclusively but the principles inform
my general philosophy of teaching. I use strategies like
Think Pair Share, Jigsaw
and Teams Games Tournaments quite a lot to get students
supporting each other. There is a poster up in my classroom
that displays the five Basic
Elements of Cooperative Learning in a wheel, suggesting
that for cooperative learning to roll along and be successful,
all five elements have to be working together. It serves
as a reminder for me as well as a teaching tool for the
students.
In
terms of displays, I guess my classroom is very idiosyncratic
in that Ive got quite a few posters of things I like
doing myself, like cycling and climbing but also things
about the weather. I try to have some of the students
work up too. I keep intending to put more things up in the
classroom about language. For example Ive got a quote
from Redgums song "I was only 19" that emphasises
alliteration. I really want kids to look at the rich and
varied way that language is used to express thought and
emotion. In terms of resources in the class, I like
to have stuff like cartridge paper on hand. Ive also
got a bookshelf with a lot of my own books and books that
Ive bought (a mixture of picture books, novels and
some short stories and poetry) so that theyre always
there. Theres quite a range. I try to have classic
texts that I can turn kids towards, although its a
bit hard to do that these days I find, because theres
so much emphasis on whats new and whats contemporary
and little valuing of whats old. I think there are
a lot more fantastic picture books and childrens novels
around now than when I was at school but some of the classics
are well worth reading and directing kids to. Ive
got a set of dog-eared dictionaries and a thesaurus so kids
can go and grab hold of them and look things up. When students
ask me what a word means, Ill direct them to the dictionary
first and foremost, and the same with spelling.

The
English program
In
terms of organising for writing, I try at certain times
to make sure that everybody is quiet, focused and absorbed
in his or her writing. I want them to be quiet, reflective,
inside their mind and to really have some sort of affinity
with what theyre writing about and how theyre
writing about it. Sometimes its a bit of a hard road
but I think its really important for continuity of
thought to just sit quietly and focus on writing. Ive
been thinking about this word work just lately.
Just get on with your work, you might say to
a kid, but it would be nice to be able to say, Get
on with your thinking.
Mostly
I try to get students to start the writing process by making
notes, trying to get some sense of where they are going.
Many students would like to plunge right in and thats
the best way for some of them to start, but I want them
to know there is another way which might just be more effective,
depending on the task and the individual student. I try
to get students to share their work, to offer constructive
criticism to one another. Often, the bulk of written work
is done in class but finished off at home away from the
distraction of others.
- using
computers - word processing, mind mapping and PowerPoint
| My
classroom is beside a room full of computers. I feel quite
privileged in having computers right next to me - its
really good to be able to just say, OK would you
like to go ahead and put that onto the computer.
Im a left-handed person and I just hate actually
putting pen to paper, the physical act of it! I love exploring
ideas and I would like my students to feel the same way
but for some kids the physical act of writing is an incredible
disadvantage and discouragement. Some kids, particularly
boys, are unfortunate in that they dont have very
good skills in terms of penmanship, but they can sit down
in front of a computer and at least get their ideas on
paper. |
 |
Right
away it looks much better than if they laboriously wrote
it out, so their self-esteem is significantly higher. Its
part of being a boy, I think, that you like gadgets, you
like playing around with things. So to get onto the computers
and be able to put work on there, even if its just
word processing to start with, makes you more positive about
actually writing. They say, I can fix that sentence,
rather than having to go through the labour of rewriting.
I
think its always good to get a print-out to preview.
I get my students to do a "preview copy" and we
talk about the way its structured. Its so easy
to cut and paste something. I was never taught how to write
essays as a kid and even up to university my essays would
be whole long sections of sticky tape bits put together
where Id cut and paste them. Now cutting and pasting
is just so wonderfully easy, so looking at logical sequencing
of ideas is really terrific using those machines. We dont
call ours a computer lab. The main rationale is that groups
and individuals can go in there to do their work. I teach
students how to use a program like Mind Man
or the basics of PowerPoint, then well
book them in if were doing a common task, or they
can drop in for individual tasks. If there is a particular
web site that I want them to visit then Ill take them
in there or if I want them to do a particular search on
something like Australian childrens literature then
well go as a group. I think its good having
a big area that can be dual purpose in this way. It would
be so good to have three or four computers actually in the
classroom that kids could just go to when theyre doing
something right there and then.
For
a long time I was really resistant to technology
because that took the focus away from engaging with literature.
Eventually I decided that computers were coming in and there
wasnt really much we could do about it. I got a computer
and I started playing around - looking at the Internet and
so forth - and I got interested in it. Earlier I talked
about the influence of Barrie Bennetts work on cooperative
learning. (I feel fortunate in that I was involved in really
terrific professional development programs through TECL.)
Another influence was being involved in Julia Atkins
whole-brain learning program - it was just brilliant. Thats
what really switched me on to mind-mapping. I got a little
taste of it there, and when we got the Internet at home
I started playing and downloaded a few different mind-mapping
trial programs from the Web. We ended up applying for a
program called MindMan, which weve gone on to purchase
at our school. Its really fantastic in the way it
allows kids to be able to put ideas down in a form that
isnt linear, that is quite expressive and can allow
certain ideas to stand out.
They
can see relationships between ideas and use all sorts of
things like colour and shape and size and images to really
emphasise and express ideas in something other than just
black and white lock-step thinking. Thats been a lot
of fun. Kids often want to go now and do a mind-map and
its been really helpful for some kids learning to
structure writing in essays.Mind mapping helps students
organise their thinking. Its much more all brain,
without getting too technical on the way the brain works
(and I couldnt get too technical anyway!). Mind mapping
uses radial thinking and uses colour, shape, and images
and makes links between ideas. I mean if you look at an
essay or a page of written text theres no way you
can easily see the connection between ideas. Students who
have different preferred learning styles - the majority!
- are given another way to organise and present their thoughts
and feelings. Mind mappings been really good and quite
an exciting and enjoyable thing for me, rejuvenating in
a lot of ways.
| Before
MindMan I was only using graphic organising and concept
mapping in a very superficial way with brainstorming
I suppose. You wouldnt even be able to call it
concept mapping really, but the idea of brainstorming
has been around now for quite a while. Id start
with an idea with kids and then wed go out into
different directions, but mind mapping is really another
dimension because it enables you to link ideas more
easily, to emphasise ideas more easily and being able
to do it on a computer and to change things so easily
is an interesting and rewarding process. Thats
probably the most interesting and diverse thing Ive
been doing with technology. |
 |
| Above
right is an example of the kind of mind map that can be
produced using MindMan. More information can be found
on the MindMan
site. |
Most
English teachers at Clarence are using computers. We have
students e-mailing, which has great possibilities, but we
need to get our act together better on that one. Ive
had kids e-mail me their work in some cases so that they
just write me a covering note and then send me their work
as an attachment in e-mail. When it is up and running the
Web-based e-mail that is part of Windows NT is very good.
I
think that chat has great possibilities and
there are some English sites where the chats are scheduled
on books (see Book Raps for a
similar idea), there are issues forums and that sort of
thing. The one worry about the Net is that if students arent
directed by knowledgeable teachers there is enormous potential
for time-wasting.
- using
technology to teach literature
A
good example of mind mapping I have used has been with a
Nadia Wheatley novel called The Blooding which we
had sitting in our book room for quite a while. I read it
a couple of years ago and thought that it was a really fantastic
book. Id say to people if they want to look at a book
that deals with issues, complex relationships, a person
discovering who they are and so forth, this book, which
is set in Tasmania, is excellent. It kind of revolves around
environmental issues and small town politics and issues
like sexuality. They should look at that instead of Lord
of the Flies. Its contemporary and kids relate
to it strongly. One of the options I gave to the students
was to mind map the book to show how character, setting
and themes were explored. Some students were also given
the option to do PowerPoint presentations. One of the TCE
criteria is to use technology so weve been looking
at how they could do that and some students used PowerPoint.
Unfortunately we havent got multimedia computers at
our school so they couldnt build in sound as a feature,
but they downloaded pictures from the Web of rainforest
in Tasmania and used them. They typed in quotes from the
book; another person found a site on Nadia Wheatley and
actually downloaded a picture of her and stuck that on the
PowerPoint presentation they were doing. It made the presentations
just so much more alive. Quotes from the author about the
writing of the book really brought that to life. They presented
those PowerPoint presentations to other kids in the class
and really got them switched on so other kids wanted to
do PowerPoint straight after that.
| So
it was pretty exciting and it really had a big impact.
It wasnt just straight essay writing again or
even giving a talk because what they had to do was give
a PowerPoint presentation and speak about it when they
presented it to the class. There were a couple of boys
who decided to meld the two technologies. They did mind
maps of relationships between various people in The
Blooding and then stuck that onto PowerPoint by
copying it to the clipboard and then copying it to PowerPoint
on a blank page. That was really good to see because
it gave them a sense of - oh, this is really quite professional
- they felt quite proud of their work. And it was good
and I felt very proud of them for the work they did
too. It was really exciting. |
 |
I
really love poetry and I make sure I do a fair bit of poetry
every year with students, every year group. Im pretty
old-fashioned in that I like to hear poetry, I dont
like to just to see it written down. With Grades 7 and 8
usually what I do is I have a whole lot of books
there and Ill say "OK grab a couple of books,
find a poem you like and then lets hear it".
And Ill be doing the same thing, Ill find a
poem. Sometimes my poems are the sorts of ones theyll
choose but often theyre ones that I think maybe will
be a bit different. Ill talk about why I like them
and then Ill increasingly try and get kids to say
a little bit about why they like a particular poem. Is it
just the sound of it, is it the sound of the words, or is
it the way it made you feel about something, what do they
see, that sort of thing.
With
grade 9 and 10, usually I start talking about music. Ill
ask them about the songs they listen to: what are some of
the lyrics, what about the lyrics of a commercial on TV
or a jingle on the radio? Gradually then things will start
coming out. I tend to mix music in with poetry in the older
grades. There are some good books around that tend to mix
poetry and music. One called Nobody But Yourself,
for example has got a nice mixture. I try to make them see
the link so they dont think poetry is something dead
that only old fogies like me are interested in. But I also
try to have a big range of poetry styles, from Shakespeare
to Geoff Goodfellow, from stuff thats really up front
and challenging and raw to stuff thats more quiet
and refined but expressive. We even go back to the occasional
bit of John Donne with the year 9s and 10s. Every once in
a while Ill play for a class a wonderful Ralph Richardson
recording of "The Rime of the Ancient Mariner"
so they can hear the power of the words, you know, the rain
coming down. So a big range! I require students to memorise
and recite poetry because I think it somehow becomes a part
of them that way; they are able to identify with the poets
voice more once they are prepared to do that.
This
year I did a unit with my Grade 9 looking at popular or
contemporary television texts. Were trying to basically
have a good look at how a program is built,
so students start by looking at how many different scenes
there are, how many storylines are running through each
episode and whats the point of each one - what disaster
is it this week, that sort of thing. Its quite good
because theyve become a bit more critical and reflective
about the soapies.
Usually
with that its quite easy to get kids to do a bit of
homework because of course they have to watch some episodes
of Home and Away so theyve got excuses for
their parents.
Thats
part of the way I organise for viewing. Every year Ill
want to show at least one feature film but then with some
classes well do viewing through popular drama as well
as examining the advertisements are constructed both on
TV and in magazines and occasionally newspapers. We look
at use of colour, composition, imagery and symbolism, written
text style, that sort of thing.
Its
a challenge to try and make sure that youre getting
a full range of texts in. Its a big balancing act.
Im constantly trying to fight against my tendency
to go deeper and deeper into a film, a novel or even a documentary
on flood victims to not just pull it all apart and look
at the pieces but not just to pull it all apart but to try
to give the kids a real affinity with it. I have just finished
reading Odo Hirschs Antonio S and the Mystery of
Theodore Gutzman, which was a warm, funny, sad kids
book that I got my teeth right into, but I dont want
to return it to the library yet. I want to hang onto it,
its just so wonderful. I like kids to feel that way
about their books but I would like them to give them back
to the library before too much time passes! Texts should
help kids empathise with the human condition of others,
like Shane in Way Home or Tish in When She Hollers
or Grommit in The Wrong Trousers!

Self
Evaluation and reflection
What
I like most about the way my class has been working this year
has to do with the computer room being there. You cant
be in two places at once even though the rooms right
next door, so Ive just had to learn to step back a little
bit and not always feel that I have to be in control (I am
a bit of a control freak!). Ive tried to allow kids
a little bit more free rein. Just being able to step back
a little bit has always been a bit hard for me and Ive
got a bit better at that. I think maybe the increased space
might help my students become a bit more reflective in what
they do. However, the big window from my room to the computer
area helps security and communication. I can see whats
happening next door and if I am not pleased, an imperiously
eloquent wave of the hand is usually quite effective!
| Usually
I think Ive got a pretty good idea of where I
want to go with things and if its not quite working
Ill stop and talk to the kids about it. Ill
ask them whats wrong, whats not happening.
Like everyone I guess, Im always trying new things
and that keeps the job interesting. Coming to terms
with the English statement and profile has been challenging
but renewing. The buzz you get when you see a great
piece of work from a student, or better still, an assignment
done really well by the whole class, is the best evidence
that youve been successful. And I think thats
about it!.
|
 |

|
|
|
 |
 |
|
 |
|